Posts Tagged :

Does Marital Therapy Work

“My Therapist Says Divorce!” – Listener Question
150 150 Lee H. Baucom, Ph.D.

The therapist announced that the marriage was over and there was no hope. She told the client that she needed to accept it. What happened? Why did it happen? What now?“In our very first session, our therapist told me that we were divorcing and I need to accept it,” Claire wrote.

I invited people to submit questions. And Claire did. (You can, too, by EMAILING HERE.)

Here is what happened:  Claire wanted to save her marriage.  Her husband thought it was over.  Claire convinced him to go to therapy.  But then, near the end of the first session (and as it turns out, the only session), the therapist turned to Claire and announced that the marriage was over and she needed to accept it.

Claire was shocked.  No efforts to work on the relationship. No discussion on what might be possible.  Just a declaration that the marriage was over… not from her husband, but from the therapist!

I only wish this was the first time to have heard pretty much the same story… but I have heard it over and over.  Does a therapist have a right to announce that divorce is inevitable? Should a therapist work on the relationship first?

Let’s talk about 3 dangers that come up for therapy… and what to do about them.

RELATED RESOURCES
Can Therapy Help?
The Dangers of Marital Therapy
Myths of Marital Therapy

What Your Therapist Won’t Tell You
Am I Against Therapy?

How To Start
System To Save Your Marriage
CLICK TO EMAIL A QUESTION

 

Am I Against Therapy?
150 150 Lee H. Baucom, Ph.D.

Am I against marital therapy, therapists, and counseling?I spent way more time in school than I would like.  To be honest, I never enjoyed school.  Not when I was a kid.  Not in high school.  Not in college.  And not in 3 rounds of grad school (2 Master’s and 1 Ph.D.).

But I spent that time in school because I had a goal.  To be a therapist.  So, I did extensive training, focusing on marriage and family therapy.

So why am I critical of therapy?

Partly because I have seen it from the inside.  Partly because I have seen the outcome studies of therapy — particularly marital therapy.

Which raises the question:  am I opposed to therapy?

The answer:  not in theory.  And not even in some specifics.

When couples are ready to make changes, and when they work with a therapist who is specifically trained in marriage and family therapy theory, and who is skilled… the outcome can be excellent.

I know many couples who have benefitted.  And I know some pretty amazing therapists.

But overall, the stats are not good.  At least, in terms of saving marriages.  1/2 of all marriages that get therapy end up divorced — the same stat that applies to the general population.

There are some specific reasons why therapy often falls short.  Some have to do with therapy/therapist.  Some have to do with clients/couples.

I discuss why there are issues in this week’s Save The Marriage Podcast.

RELATED RESOURCES:
How To NOT Save Your Marriage
Problems with Therapy
What Your Therapist WON’T Tell You
How to Guarantee Therapy FAILS

If you have tried therapy and it didn’t work, or if you don’t want to do therapy, please grab my Save The Marriage System